Risk factors for adverse birth outcomes for the child
It is well established that women experiencing common or severe mental disorders are at higher risk of adverse obstetric outcomes, including preterm birth and foetal growth impairments (Howard & Khalifeh, 2020). Several studies have highlighted the link between parental health and well-being, particularly that of the mother, and premature birth. Preterm birth is associated with negative health, social and educational outcomes for children (McHale et al., 2022).
Even moderate mental health symptoms can affect birth outcomes, although multiple contributing factors must be considered, such as chronic medical conditions, domestic violence and socioeconomic adversity (Staneva et al., 2015). Poor maternal general health, including physical, mental and social domains, and chronic or autoimmune conditions are associated with poorer long-term outcomes for children (Mudiyanselage et al., 2024).
Depression during pregnancy has been found to increase the risk of preterm birth and low birth weight (Grote et al., 2010). Research has demonstrated a significant association between preterm birth and depression, anxiety and perceived stress during pregnancy (Staneva et al., 2015), and pregnancy-specific stress, which combines anxiety and elevated stress, is a strongly predictive factor (Evans & Bullock, 2012). Maternal eating disorders have been associated with restricted foetal growth, preterm birth, abnormal head size and increased perinatal mortality (Ecob et al., 2025).
Untreated maternal depression during pregnancy may lead to foetal stress responses, neurochemical alterations in newborns and later behavioural problems (Gentile, 2017). In utero exposure to maternal depression is linked to changes in the serotonergic system and the hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal axis, probably mediated through maternal–placental–foetal stress mechanisms, including immune activation (Howard & Khalifeh, 2020). Maternal antenatal anxiety has been linked to increased preterm birth rates, lower Apgar scores, shorter birth length and poorer developmental trajectories (Dennis et al., 2017).
Risk factors for negative or traumatic experiences
Individuals with prior mental health issues may be more prone to intense stress responses, which can worsen childbirth-related trauma. Conditions such as anxiety, depression or trauma are known risk factors for postpartum PTSD (Orovou et al., 2025). A difficult birth experience may also increase the risk of relapse among individuals with a history of mental health disorders, such as bipolar disorder (Sharma et al., 2024). Mothers who give birth to twins or triplets are more likely to experience postpartum depression and stress compared to those giving birth to a single child (Van den Akker et al., 2016).
The mode of delivery has also been found to play a role as a risk factor for PTSD (Silva-Fernandez et al., 2023). The prevalence of maternal PTSD following emergency caesarean sections ranged from 2% to 41% in a review by Orovou and colleagues (2025). High PTSD rates following emergency caesarean sections are influenced by the clinical urgency of the procedure, its unexpected nature and pre-existing maternal vulnerabilities (Orovou et al., 2025). Other risk factors for PTSD include childhood trauma (Racine et al., 2021), intimate partner violence (Howard et al., 2013), disaster exposure (Harville et al., 2010), perinatal loss (Burden et al., 2016), fear of childbirth (Molgora et al., 2019) and traumatic or negative birth experiences, including obstetric violence (Frankham et al., 2023; Silva-Fernandez et al., 2023).
Impacts of negative birth experience
Traumatic births significantly impact emotional and psychological health, resulting in shame, low mood avoidance of memories and reminders and persistent intrusive memories. These factors can contribute to the development of trauma-related symptoms, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and postpartum depression (Bell et al., 2016), as well as anxiety and stress (McCarthy et al., 2021). Mothers may struggle to bond with their babies, while relationships with partners, family and friends can deteriorate. (Shorey et al., 2022). Postpartum and birth-related PTSD can severely impair maternal well-being and early bonding (Furuta et al., 2018).
Childbirth experiences have also been examined from the father’s perspective. A negative birth experience can be a risk factor for psychological trauma in fathers after childbirth. Stress, anxiety and fear during labour are associated with paternal PTSD symptoms and other forms of mental health challenges, and they can lead to difficulties in relationships with the partner and infant. These may be further aggravated by the lower ability of fathers to seek help for mental health issues (McNab et al., 2022). To cope, fathers often rely on avoidance and emotional suppression, although some couples have strengthened their bond through shared traumatic experiences (Shorey et al., 2022). Fathers have reported that poor communication with healthcare professionals, a lack of preparation and exclusion during childbirth are associated with their negative childbirth experiences (McNab et al., 2022). Parents have used various coping strategies after negative experiences, including acknowledging and discussing their trauma, seeking information about birth events and turning to religious faith. Many mothers use positive emotions and childcare activities as way to prevent their trauma symptoms from impacting their infants. Both parents have reported valuing social and professional support, while informal networks such as peer groups and online forums provide a sense of community (Shorey et al., 2022).
Negative birth experiences and the quality of care
In addition to the negative birth experiences described earlier, the quality of interaction in care and services in general is significant for maternal well-being. Negative birth experiences may result from a contradiction between childbirth expectations and actual experiences, a lack of control during labour, negative interactions with healthcare professionals and inadequate pain management (Benyamini et al., 2024). Common themes associated with traumatic experiences across studies include feelings of disappointment, unmet expectations and emotional distress following childbirth (Bell & Andersson, 2016). Shorey & Wong (2022) pointed out that parents have expressed various factors that led to their traumatic birth experiences. Parents commonly reported dismissive attitudes of healthcare providers, feelings of powerlessness and fear for the safety of the mother and infant. Their constant battles to overcome traumatic experiences have also affected their relationships. To deal with the trauma, some mothers displayed avoidance behaviours while others relied on social support.
Poor communication, limited information-sharing, insufficient decision-making involvement of midwives and a lack of support and trust in midwives have been identified as risk factors for developing postpartum PTSD (Patterson et al., 2019). Parents with traumatic birth experiences described a lack of agency, coercion, routine- or outcome-centred care, unexpected interventions and experiences of obstetric violence as factors leading to traumatic experiences. Physical pain led to trauma and difficulties, and unexpected medical interventions or experiences of obstetric violation could have serious postpartum implications for women during childbirth. Healthcare professionals should provide empathetic communication, involve fathers actively during childbirth and offer counselling to both parents. Postpartum interventions should include education about normal and emergency birth scenarios, emotional support and access to peer groups. Recognising avoidance behaviours early and addressing them through professional care can prevent long-term psychological harm (Shorey & Chan, 2020).
Healthcare professionals are in a critical role in shaping birth outcomes and need to recognise and systematically assess pregnancy-specific psychological trauma (PSPT) across all perinatal individuals to improve care and outcomes (Shorey & Wong, 2022). Adequate and sensitive support during birth can prevent negative experiences and PTSD. It could be easily implemented in different care settings and can be even more important for women with a history of trauma or instrumental birth (Ayers et al., 2016). This emphasises the need for trauma-informed care practices during labour and delivery (Givrad et al., 2025).
A lack of decision-making opportunities during childbirth increases the risk of later mental health issues (Arnold et al., 2025). Some studies have pointed out the concept of ‘obstetric violence’ as a significant risk factor for parental mental health disorders, including an increased risk of postpartum depression and PTSD (Silva-Fernandez et al., 2023). Obstetric violence is understood as a violation of women’s rights during childbirth, including disrespect, inhumane treatment and verbal, psychological or physical abuse. Reports from high-income countries include a lack of pain relief, ignoring requests for help, yelling and scolding (Fraser et al., 2025).
The importance of adequate support
A positive birth experience is associated with the mother’s possibility to participate in decision-making during birth (Arnold et al., 2025), and with support, guidance and positive interaction from healthcare professionals (Benyamini et al., 2024). A sense of being respected and valued has produced positive perceptions among mothers (Miyauchi et al., 2022). A positive birth experience is identified as a protective factor against postpartum depression (Bell & Andersson, 2016; Silva-Fernandez et al., 2023). A positive experience can also protect against birth-related PTSD and can be supported by safe communication with healthcare professionals and showing respect for the birth plan (Silva-Fernandez et al., 2023).
The importance of good preparation for childbirth is emphasised in contributing to a better experience of childbirth for mothers and their partners (Benyamini et al., 2014). Continuity of care through a familiar midwife alongside the mother’s perinatal care is associated with reduced depression and anxiety symptoms during the perinatal period (Cibralic et al., 2023). An early connection with midwives and the availability of postnatal home midwifery services were found to be positive factors in the successful transition to motherhood (Walker et al., 2019). A harmonic relationship and negotiating with mothers outside strict protocols also positively influence the relationship with professionals (Curtin et al., 2023). For fathers, inclusion and good communication with midwives support more positive birth experiences. Feeling included contributes to more positive parenthood, improved partner relationships and better family well-being (McNab et al., 2022; Palioura et al., 2023).