
Iodine reduction | 90% reduction for 2 min at 45 °C, slow effect at 30 °C (A, S) 1-3 | 90% reduction for 4 min at 45 °C not at 35 °C. Can be enhanced using successive water baths (S) 4 | 90% reduction for 2 min (S) 5, 6 | 90–95% reduction for 1.5–2 min (S) 5, 7 | 25–68% reduction (A, S) 2, 8-10 | 85% reduction with US treatment at 45 °C for 30 min (A) 9. Moderate effect on Laminaria hyperborea 11 | Marginal reduction (S) 12, 13 |
PTEs reduction | Only reduction of As (A, S) 10, 13 | Only reduction of As (S) 4, 13 | Only reduction of As (S) 6 | Only reduction of As (A, S) 2, 8-10 | Only reduction of As (A) 10 | (S) 12, 13 | |
Microbial safety | (A, S) 14, 15 | (S) 5 | Inactivation of microbes | Inactivation of microbes although no sterilization | Inactivation of microbes | ||
Mineral retention | Losses of Na, K (S) 13 | Uptake of Na, loss of K | (S) 16 | (S) 5 | Generally high retention, some K losses (S) 9 | (A) 10 | (S) 12, 13 |
Protein retention | (S) 9, 16 | (S) 16 | (A, S) 2, 9, 10 | (A) 10 | (S) 12, 13 | ||
Flavour retention | Mild flavour (S) 13 | (S) 13, 17 | (S) 14 | Reduction in saltiness and umami 17 | Not sign. different flavour compared to blanched or PEF-treated kelp but more rubbery texture and less green colour (A) 10 | (S) 13 | |
Other bioactives | Can concentrate some bioactives (e.g, polyphenols) while heat will degrade others (e.g., pigments, vitamins) (S) 1, 3, 5, 7 | No thermal degradation | No thermal degradation | Preservation of bioactives during subsequent storage (S) 12 | |||
Energy consumption | High. Depends on volume of water ex: 150 kJ/kg for 0.5 kg kelp in 5 kg water at 45 °C 8 | High. Specific heat capacity of seawater slightly lower than FW but not a large influence on total energy input | High. Depends on volume of water ex: 340 kJ/kg for 0.5 kg kelp in 5 kg water at 95 °C 8 | High. Specific heat capacity of seawater slightly lower than FW but not a large influence on total energy input | Low. Vary depending on pulse count (3 - 53 KJ kg-1) 8, 9 | Low. 59 kJ/kg 10 | Assumed to be closed to that of hot water blanching |
Investment costs | |||||||
Operating costs | |||||||
On-board op. possible | |||||||
References: 1 Nielsen et al. (2020); 2 Blikra et al. (2024b); 3 Stévant et al. (2017a); 4 Stévant et al. (2025a); 5 Wirenfeldt et al. (2022); 6 Blikra et al. (2021b); 7 Lafeuille et al. (2023b); 8 Blikra et al. (2022b); 9 Sund et al. (2025b); 10 Sund et al. (2025a); 11 Noriega-Fernández et al. (2021); 12 Stévant et al. (2024); 13 Krook et al. (2023); 14 Akomea-Frempong et al. (2021) ; 15 Blikra et al. (2018); 16 Trigo et al. (2023); 17 Stévant et al. (in prep.). | |||||||
Iodine reduction | (S) 1 | (S) 1 | Some iodine leaches into the liquid (A, S) 2, 3 | Some iodine leaches into the liquid upon thawing (A, S) 4, 5 | Iodine leaches into the liquid (S) 6 | Some iodine leaches (S) 5 | Iodine leaches into the liquid (S) 5 Around 60% reduction of iodine by ≥ 20% NaCl (S) 23 |
PTEs reduction | Lower tot. As and Cd (A, S) 2 | Some As may be reduced (A, S) 4, 5 | Lower tot. As and Cd (S) 6 | Some reduction of As and Cd (S) 5 | Cd reduction at 2.0 M NaCl (A) 7 | ||
Microbial safety | Some pathogens may survive (A, S) 8, 9 | Safe if low pH (< 4.3) is rapidly achieved and maintained (A, S) 10, 11 | Safe if cold chain maintained and if contamination of spore-forming bacteria avoided (A) 12 | At pH below 4 (A, S) 6, 13 | Reduces water activity. Shelf life prolonged for some weeks when combined with refrigerated storage (A, S) 14, 15 | Reduces water activity. Shelf life prolonged for some weeks or when preserved with ≥ 20% NaCl, up to a year when combined with refrigerated storage. (S) 15, 23 | |
Mineral retention | (S, P) 1, 16 | (S) 1 | Some minerals (e.g., K) may leach into the liquid | High drip loss removes some soluble minerals (Na, K mainly) (A, S) 4, 5 | Mainly loss of K (S) 6 | Na is added but other minerals (e.g., K) may leach (A, S) 5, 14 | Na is added but other minerals (e.g., K) may leach (A, S) |
Protein retention | (S, P) 1, 16 | (S, P) 1, 17, 18 | (S) 3 | (A) 4 | (A, S) 6, 13 | ||
Flavour retention | Stable flavour at low moisture content (S) 1, 2 | (S) 1 | Sourness increases with storage (A) 2 | Develops “green” aromas (P) 19 | Sourness increases with storage (A, S) 6, 13 | Increases saltiness | Increases saltiness |
Other bioactives | Oxidation of pigments and antioxidants may occur (S, P, U) 1, 16, 18, 20 | Pigments may be degraded while pre- and probiotic activity may increase 21. Lower extractable polyphenols | Enzymatic degradation (e.g., pigments) (S) 5 | A, S 6, 13 Antioxidant activity decreases | Some losses expected but data missing | Some losses expected but data missing | |
Energy consumption | May require temperature control | Freezing + frozen storage | May require temperature control | Requires refrigeration | Requires refrigeration | ||
Investment costs | Fermentation tanks | Industrial freezer + warehouse packaging systems | Containers for acidified storage | Cold storage | Cold storage | ||
Operating costs | Energy costs | Energy costs | Starter culture (unless spontaneous), pH monitoring | Energy + handling (incl. packaging) 22 | Will depend on choice of acid (and costs) and handling | Energy for cold storage | Energy for cold storage |
On-board op. possible | Require power supply and space on vessel | Needs adapted vessels & hygiene control | Require power supply and space on vessel | ||||
References: 1 Stévant et al. (2018b); 2 Stévant et al. (in prep.); 3 Bruhn et al. (2019); 4 Sund et al. (2024); 5 Stévant et al. (2024); 6 Krook et al. (2024); 7 ; 8 Sørensen et al. (2023); 9 Lytou et al. (2021); 10 ; 11 Sørensen et al. (2021); 12 Blikra et al. (2018); 13 Hrólfsdóttir et al. (2024); 14 Perry et al. (2019); 15 Arya et al. (2024); 16 Lafeuille et al. (2023a); 17 Abdollahi et al. (2019); 18 Stévant (2019); 19 Le Pape et al. (2002); 20 Silva et al. (2019); 21 Monteiro et al. (2021); 22 Stévant and Rebours (2021); 23 Klein et al. (under review). | |||||||
Iodine reduction | (S) 1 | (S) 1 | Some iodine leaches into the liquid (A, S) 2, 3 | Some iodine leaches into the liquid upon thawing (A, S) 4, 5 | Iodine leaches into the liquid (S) 6 | Some iodine leaches (S) 5 | Iodine leaches into the liquid (S) 5 Around 60% reduction of iodine by ≥ 20% NaCl (S) 23 |
PTEs reduction | Lower tot. As and Cd (A, S) 2 | Some As may be reduced (A, S) 4, 5 | Lower tot. As and Cd (S) 6 | Some reduction of As and Cd (S) 5 | Cd reduction at 2.0 M NaCl (A) 7 | ||
Microbial safety | Some pathogens may survive (A, S) 8, 9 | Safe if low pH (< 4.3) is rapidly achieved and maintained (A, S) 10, 11 | Safe if cold chain maintained and if contamination of spore-forming bacteria avoided (A) 12 | At pH below 4 (A, S) 6, 13 | Reduces water activity. Shelf life prolonged for some weeks when combined with refrigerated storage (A, S) 14, 15 | Reduces water activity. Shelf life prolonged for some weeks or when preserved with ≥ 20% NaCl, up to a year when combined with refrigerated storage. (S) 15, 23 | |
Mineral retention | (S, P) 1, 16 | (S) 1 | Some minerals (e.g., K) may leach into the liquid | High drip loss removes some soluble minerals (Na, K mainly) (A, S) 4, 5 | Mainly loss of K (S) 6 | Na is added but other minerals (e.g., K) may leach (A, S) 5, 14 | Na is added but other minerals (e.g., K) may leach (A, S) |
Protein retention | (S, P) 1, 16 | (S, P) 1, 17, 18 | (S) 3 | (A) 4 | (A, S) 6, 13 | ||
Flavour retention | Stable flavour at low moisture content (S) 1, 2 | (S) 1 | Sourness increases with storage (A) 2 | Develops “green” aromas (P) 19 | Sourness increases with storage (A, S) 6, 13 | Increases saltiness | Increases saltiness |
Other bioactives | Oxidation of pigments and antioxidants may occur (S, P, U) 1, 16, 18, 20 | Pigments may be degraded while pre- and probiotic activity may increase 21. Lower extractable polyphenols | Enzymatic degradation (e.g., pigments) (S) 5 | A, S 6, 13 Antioxidant activity decreases | Some losses expected but data missing | Some losses expected but data missing | |
Energy consumption | May require temperature control | Freezing + frozen storage | May require temperature control | Requires refrigeration | Requires refrigeration | ||
Investment costs | Fermentation tanks | Industrial freezer + warehouse packaging systems | Containers for acidified storage | Cold storage | Cold storage | ||
Operating costs | Energy costs | Energy costs | Starter culture (unless spontaneous), pH monitoring | Energy + handling (incl. packaging) 22 | Will depend on choice of acid (and costs) and handling | Energy for cold storage | Energy for cold storage |
On-board op. possible | Require power supply and space on vessel | Needs adapted vessels & hygiene control | Require power supply and space on vessel | ||||
References: 1 Stévant et al. (2018b); 2 Stévant et al. (in prep.); 3 Bruhn et al. (2019); 4 Sund et al. (2024); 5 Stévant et al. (2024); 6 Krook et al. (2024); 7 ; 8 Sørensen et al. (2023); 9 Lytou et al. (2021); 10 ; 11 Sørensen et al. (2021); 12 Blikra et al. (2018); 13 Hrólfsdóttir et al. (2024); 14 Perry et al. (2019); 15 Arya et al. (2024); 16 Lafeuille et al. (2023a); 17 Abdollahi et al. (2019); 18 Stévant (2019); 19 Le Pape et al. (2002); 20 Silva et al. (2019); 21 Monteiro et al. (2021); 22 Stévant and Rebours (2021); 23 Klein et al. (under review). | |||||||

Voltage (kV) | 24 | 24 | 24 | 24 | 24 | 24 |
Frequency (Hz) | 30 | 30 | 30 | 30 | 30 | 30 |
Pulse duration (µs) | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 |
Pulse count | 200 | 800 | 300 | 200 | 500 | 800 |
Energy (kJ) | 2.7 | 14 | 11 | 11 | 28 | 46 |
Ground/whole kelp | Whole | Whole | Ground | Ground | Ground | Ground |
Water: seaweed ratio | 10:1 | 10:1 | 2:1 | 2:1 | 2:1 | 2:1 |
Iodine | 42% | 38% | 50% | 2.5% | 3.3% | 25% |
Arsenic | 11% | 12% | 1.4% | 0% | 0% | 0% |




Freeze-drying | Very high | Up to 22 | Suited for high-value products |
Hot air belt dryer | High | n.d. | Possible thermal degradations |
Hot air cabinets | High | n.d. | Flexible but often limited capacity |
Hot air drum of mill dryer | High | 1.2 | Possible thermal degradations |
Low temp. dehumidified air drying | Moderate | n.d. | Minimises heat damage |
Superheated steam mill dryer | Moderate | 0.75 | Possible thermal degradation. No oxidation. |
Spray drying | High | 1.3–3.2 | Suitable for liquids and slurries |
Refractance window drying ™ | High | 2.3–3.2 | Suitable for liquids and slurries |
Microwave drying | Moderate | 0.6–2.2 | Often used as a first drying step |
Microwave vacuum drying | High | 8.1 | Very quick. Avoids heat damage. |
Radio frequency drying | Moderate | n.d. | Usually, final drying step |
Infrared drying | Very high | 14.5 | Limited to thin layer products |
Outdoor/solar drying | Low | n.d. | Weather dependant |
n.d.: no data. | |||