Future perspectives
The ability of AK to retain phosphate in the sediment is a promising result that shows the potential of AK for use in remediation of eutrophic waters. A small dose of 600 g/m2 completely stopped the phosphate release from the sediment. This dose is similar to doses of aluminum chloride that have been injected in eutrophic lake sediments (Schütz, Rydin, and Huser 2017). For 16 lakes remediated with Phoslock™, an average dose of ca 300 g/ m2 was applied (Spears et al. 2013). Before such field applications, the pool of available phosphorus in the sediments is determined and the dose is calculated accordingly. Doses will therefore vary depending on the site. The AK increased porewater concentrations of phosphate which is an effect that must be studied further. However, the phosphate was entrapped in the sediment porewater in the AK treatments, possibly to small iron or other mineral hydroxides smaller than 0.45 µm in size (thus passing through the filter during phosphate measurement). Porewater phosphate can be mobilized following adverse episodes, such as resuspension caused by storms, or physico-chemical alterations following, e.g., climate change. If the increased pH caused the raised porewater phosphate, it is not likely that it would occur in a field situation where buffering capacity against pH changes is high. Furthermore, the partitioning of phosphorus, i.e., how it allocates to bioavailable forms or is trapped by the sorbent or sediment, could change in a longer experiment. A future pilot-scale study must therefore further assess these effects under a long time-period.
To summarize, this study showed that the novel activated limestone trapped phosphate in the sediment effectively, which was the purpose of the amendment, and that the material had no effects on other important sediment processes such as methane formation. There is no universal method to remediate all eutrophic waters due to their ecological and geological variability and complexity. It is, thus, important to continue to develop and test new techniques in the field.
This report was reviewed and improved by Elias Broman, Department of Ecology, Environment and Plant Sciences, Stockholm University, 2023-11-23.
This research was funded by The Nordic Council of Ministers, project number 23002.