One example of this was the fact that, among the six participants who experienced mental health problems, only one stated that there were outreach initiatives from their school during their school years. The others only got help after they dropped out.
A study that addressed the conditions and circumstances that risk leading to a status of NEET was conducted in Northern Norway in a multicultural young adult population (Bania, Eckhoff & Kvernmo, 2019). The purpose of this study was to investigate predictors of a NEET status: its frequency and development over time. The study is based on self-reports from the participants followed up by a study based on register analyses 8–10 years later. In the first study, all 5877 year 10 pupils in Northern Norway aged 15–16 years participated, representing 83% of the total age group from all 87 municipalities. The follow-up studies included 3987 young people, 365 of whom were of Sami ethnicity.
The study showed that a NEET status in young adulthood was clearly higher among women (20.9%) than among men (16.2%). There were ethnic differences too: a NEET status among Sami men was clearly higher than among non-Sami men, being 23.0% and 15.2%, respectively. The study identified important causes of a NEET status. In male participants, these causes concerned peer problems, behavioural problems and musculoskeletal problems. Hyperactivity problems and relationship problems were associated with a NEET status emerging later among young women. The level of education of the participants’ parents was an important factor for a NEET status, where a low level of education is clearly associated with a NEET status subsequently emerging among both young adult men and women.
A Swedish qualitative in-depth study identified emotional stages that can be associated with the development of a NEET status (Hammarström & Ahlgren, 2019). In this longitudinal study, how young people classified as NEET experienced their health was analysed in relation to their position in the labour market, from the time of having left school to early adulthood. The study included six women and eight men in a town in northern Sweden who had become unemployed immediately after completing compulsory school. In-person interviews were conducted regularly with them from the age of 16 to the age of 33. The study shows that how they perceive their health develops through different phases: leaving school, entering the labour market, being unemployed, and gaining employment. The informants’ experiences during each of these phases included feelings of disappointment and setbacks, hopelessness and resignation, and finally – in the case of the individual finally getting a job – feeling that they needed to accept an adverse work situation. The study shows that how a person experiences their health can be linked to both context and process and was related to these different phases. It is a process where the young person initially feels relief and hope on completing compulsory school, but then entry into the labour market is related to setbacks and disappointments as well as both health-impairing and health-promoting experiences, depending on their actual position in the labour market. The overall theme of the study Living in the shadow of unemployment – an unhealthy life situation means that it is not only the actual situation of being unemployed that is problematic, but that the other phases are coloured by the young person’s previous experiences of unemployment. The study highlights that social processes affect and interact with how the individual experiences their health.
Tools to prevent NEET
It is important to investigate what can prevent and counteract a NEET status. Norwegian register data were used to investigate whether early work experience in the teenage years (16–18 years) can help young people at risk of becoming NEETs to improve their chances of getting work or gaining entry to education and training programmes as a young adult, and whether early work experience is a protective factor (Ballo, Heglum, Nilsen & Bernstrøm, 2022). An entire birth cohort of about 50,000 individuals was included in the study and this cohort was followed from ages 16 to 29 years. The results show that early work experience is related to a lower risk of NEET for all, but the link was stronger for young people with disabilities and for young people who left school early. This finding supports the importance of early work experience as a potentially important protective factor against a later NEET status, especially among vulnerable young people.
That depressive symptoms are associated with unemployment is already known, but a Danish study investigated whether the timing and duration of depressive symptoms in the teenage years, or education level attained, affect NEET in young adulthood (at 23 years of age) (Veldman et al., 2022). The incidence of depressive symptoms was measured on three occasions: at the ages of 14, 18 and 21. Among boys, depressive symptoms at ages 14 and 21 increased the risk of NEET. Among girls, this risk was related to depressive symptoms at ages 18 and 21. The duration of depressive symptoms among boys increased the risk of NEET. Among girls, only prolonged depressive symptoms increased the risk of NEET. Thus, both the timing and duration of depressive symptoms in the teenage years are significant for a NEET status in young adulthood. Those with both depressive symptoms and low levels of education are particularly at risk. The results underline the importance of support for those experiencing depressive symptoms in the transition from school to work. In addition, the study suggests that boys who exhibit depressive symptoms in their early teens need attention.
Early exclusion from the labour market entails a risk of mental ill-health and impaired well-being. In a Norwegian study, self-perceived causes of ill-health and social and health-related problems were investigated among young adults at risk of early work disability (Sveinsdottir, Eriksen, Baste, Hetland & Reme, 2018). 96 young adults participated in the study, the average age was 24 years, and two-thirds were men. One third of the young adults in the study reported reading and writing difficulties, and 40% had an education level lower than an upper secondary school qualification. The majority had experienced bullying (66%) or violence (39%) and 53% reported dangerous alcohol use.
Anxiety is the most common health problem, and women generally report more physical and mental health problems than men. Self-perceived causes are mainly related to relationship problems followed by health behaviours, heredity/genetics and external environmental factors. This study provides an in-depth insight into a vulnerable group’s significant challenges related to negative social experiences, anxiety and alcohol use. Relationship problems are highlighted as the main cause of ill-health.
In the same study population as above, the authors also examined whether Supported Employment (IPS, Swedish abbreviation for individuell placering och stöd) can be an effective initiative to help people with mental illnesses to gain employment (Sveinsdottir et al., 2020). Young adults in particular are at risk of early work disability due to various social and health-related problems. Participants who belonged to the NEET group received temporary benefits due to social or health-related problems and were eligible for traditional vocational rehabilitation (TYR, Swedish abbreviation for "traditionell yrkesinriktad rehabilitering”). Self-reported data was collected at the start and at six- and twelve-month follow-ups. The primary goal of the participants during the follow-up period was to get some form of paid employment in the competitive labour market. Physical and mental health, well-being, coping, alcohol consumption and drug use were also investigated.
Significantly more IPS participants had got jobs in the competitive labour market compared to TYR participants at the 12-month follow-up: 48% versus 8%. The IPS group reported significantly better results than the TYR group on subjective assessments of health problems, helplessness and hopelessness. The IPS group also reported significantly better results in terms of disability levels, optimism about future well-being, and drug use. The study shows that supported employment is more effective than vocational rehabilitation for young adults at risk of early work disability in gaining employment in the competitive labour market.