Access to handle PoAs
In Denmark, the PoA landscape is relatively consolidated comprising only a few central access points to various digital PoAs within healthcare, business, and taxation sectors. The key platform solution is Digital fuldmagt (public PoAs incl. for healthcare and business PoAs when accessing from Virk), along with tastselvborger and tastselverhverv (taxation), as well as MitID Erhverv and Virk (business). To a large extent, PoAs can be handled, stored, and used digitally.
Danish citizens can access and manage PoAs related to the healthcare sector (along with a range of other public PoAs), through the platform solution, Digital fuldmagt, developed by the Danish Agency for Digitalisation.
Danish taxation matters are divided into two platform solutions for citizen and business respectively. For citizens and residents, taxation PoAs are handled and managed on tastselvborger, while businesses handle them on tastselverhverv (from here “TastSelv”). On these platforms, users can choose to login to their own account or that of someone from who they have been assigned a PoA to access.
For the
business sector, businesses can assign PoAs to employees, other organisations, and external consultants (e.g. accountants or lawyers) on the platform solutions
MitID Erhverv and Virk. MitID Erhverv is its own solution, from which PoAs can be granted and managed, whereas
Virk directs users to a business version of
digital fuldmagt, working identically to
digital fuldmagt, but with business oriented PoAs. The PoAs can grant varying levels of access and authority, e.g. access to financial reporting, execution of business transactions or signing contracts. Within the platforms, there are different variations of PoAs. For example, a CEO may grant an accountant the right to submit tax filings or financial reports, while a legal representative may be given the power to sign contracts or register company changes. Moreover, it is possible to authorize a person to make major business decisions, such as signing contracts or establishing a subsidiary. Lastly, a business authorisation solution where, typically, a representative of a small business can grant authorisations to other organisations and employees in other organisations. The platform solutions for the business sector are rather mature since businesses have their own digital identity via
MitID Erhverv, although this involves complexity (see
verification). Additionally, the presence of two platforms increases complexity as well.
Digital fuldmagt and MitID Erhverv provide national solutions compiling access to many public and business PoAs for users in a simplified way, with shared infrastructure components. However, not all sectors are covered, such as taxation and other public authorities. Nevertheless, it is in the process of being implemented across all public authorities. Overall, this complexity creates challenges, as citizens sometimes must contact individual authorities separately. Moreover, the separated solutions for taxation and business matters creates additional complexity. However, tastselvehrverv is in the process of transitioning to MitID Erhverv, which may help reduce some of the complexity.
In the Faroe Islands, there are distinct platforms for each sector, Vangin for healthcare and public matters, Borgaragluggin for taxation matters and Vinnugluggin for business, all require the national eID, Samleikin for access. From Vangin users can manage PoAs, view digital mail, view and perform online tasks related to public services. For healthcare matters, PoAs can be accessed, granted, viewed, and used on Vangin, demonstrating a high level of maturity for healthcare.
Taxation matters on the other hand require a more manual process involving filling out a PDF and signing with an electronic signature, then sending to the tax authority. After processing, assignee and assignor are notified via Minboks, in Vangin, from here, the assignee can view and utilise the PoA in Borgaragluggin and sign in as the assignor.
For business related matters, users must log into Vinnugluggin, the business equivalent of Borgaragluggin, from here business PoAs such as power to act on behalf of a company can be granted. However, similarly to taxation matters, this is also done via the submitting of a form, rather than fully on the platform. As a result, the maturity level is high for healthcare matters, slightly lower for taxation matters and business matters, resulting in intermediate maturity for the PoA landscape in the Faroe Islands.
In Greenland there is, as of today, no digital PoA solution. All PoAs are analogue and signed manually. MitID, the Danish national eID is however in use for online Banking.
Verification
In Denmark, the verification and authentication methods are standardised for handling PoAs, as they all require the national, EU-approved eID, MitID. It exists in two forms, MitID Privat (for private citizens and residents) and MitID Erhverv (for businesses). MitID is used to access all government institutions, PoAs, as well as used to verify identity and authenticate for private services such as banking and business PoAs.
MitID Privat necessitates a national identity number (CPR), which is required for all Danish citizens and residents. When first acquiring MitID Privat, verification is required via a physical picture ID such as a passport or driver’s license, which serves as a proof of identity. This method is characterised as a qualified electronic signature, that is the highest level of maturity. Moreover, a login with MitID to PoA services thus verifies the digital identity automatically. MitID Privat can also be used for business, when citizens are given rights to view or handle a business’s information by logging in to Virk or MitID Erhverv.
MitID Erhverv is the authorization solution for businesses. It enables employees, owners, or other organisations to act on behalf of the company by logging into MitID Erhverv with their personal MitID or MitiD Erhverv identity. The eID entails different solutions, depending on various factors such as ownership. To get MitID Erhverv, businesses must have a company registry number, a leadership representative and additional documentation. After the first login, administrators and user rights are assigned on the platform.
In the Faroe Islands, verification to digital PoA solutions is handled through Samleikin, the national e-ID. Samleikin works similarly to MitID privat in Denmark, in that it provides access to all online public services. Samleikin is a trusted service provider and complies with the euIDAS, despite not being a member of the EU. Additionally, Samleikin uses QES to ensure the highest level of security when processing PoAs and other activities requiring an electronic signature. As a result, the Faroes Island’s solution for verification follows a similar level of maturity to Denmark.
Authentication
In Denmark, the identity of both the assignor and assignee is authenticated using MitID, which acts as a centralized authentication solution. Accessing a PoA platform solution with MitID requires multifactor login, involving user ID to launch the MitID app on the phone, submitting a password or biometrics in the app, followed by approval in the app. This ensures that only the authorized individuals can create and use PoAs. Additionally, encryption and data security measures are built in to protect personal information throughout the entire process. The authentication level can also be considered highly secure and thereby also demonstrates an advanced level of digital PoA maturity.
In the Faroe Islands, access to Samleikin requires the Faroese social security number, (p-tal), full name, telephone number, and a picture ID such as passport or driver’s license. Samleikin is required for access to PoAs and therefore follows the same level of authentication maturity as Denmark.
Integration
In Denmark, the main PoA solution (Digital fuldmagt), along with the two others described (TastSelv and MitID Erhverv) integrate with other relevant third-party platforms to some extent. For instance, Digital fuldmagt aggregates PoAs across various sectors, and integrates healthcare PoAs to relevant platforms and entities, such as Sundhed.dk. This allows assignees to view the assignor’s health data if a PoA has been granted via Digital fuldmagt. However, the solutions face challenges as the they do not sufficiently support representation by third parties. For example, it is currently not possible to grant complex PoAs, even though citizens have the right under administrative law to authorize someone in specific cases. Furthermore, Denmark is currently exploring general authorizations that are not specific, but cross-cutting to encompass both the public and private sectors. Considering the above, the Danish PoA landscape is yet to be fully integrated into a one-stop-solution but is highly advanced.
When the assignee interacts with a third party, such as a public authority or service provider, the third party verifies the validity of the PoA by checking it through the Digital Fuldmagt system. This can involve scanning a QR code, accessing the PoA digitally, or viewing documentation that confirms the assignee’s authority. In this way, the third party can see the details of the PoA, such as its scope and duration, ensuring that the assignee has the correct permissions to act on behalf of the assignor.
In the Faroe Islands, the national eID Samleikin is integrated across public and private platforms for verification and authentication. Additionally, some integration from taxation and healthcare PoAs is possible via the Vangin platform, however, any further integration availability is either lacking or unknown. Therefore, integration maturity for the Faroe Islands is relatively low, except for the national eID.
Cross-border interoperability
Non-Danish eID holders can access Danish e-services like PoA solutions by linking their eID to a Danish CPR number, as a part of the implementation of the eIDAS-Node. Yet, non-residents face hurdles, as Denmark lacks a system to reliably identify and authorize individuals without a CPR number despite some EU countries having effective registries, which presents security and identification challenges. Establishing such a system is complex and costly.
In relation to the EU's new regulations (eID, EHDS, etc.), Denmark is thus facing the challenge of integrating additional elements into its existing solutions and creating connections to other EU countries. However, the Danish PoA and MitID solutions are considered feasible to continuously be the backbone of the Danish implementation of these regulations. Even if credentials for the right to represent a party is issued in a digital wallet (i.e. EUDIW), there will still be a need for sources to verify these credentials, and the existing authorization solutions are trusted to be well-suited for this purpose.
Additionally, processing tax matters for non-residents is challenging. Despite non-residents being liable for Danish taxes and partially served by TastSelvBorger, authorizing, and registering them in the system is fraught with difficulties, complicating accurate management of their tax-related information.
For the Faroe Islands, integration with Danish systems is not currently available, however, citizens with a Danish CPR number can acquire Samleikin, the national e-ID, to access Faroese platforms. While the Faroe Islands has an e-ID compliant with eIDAS, the Faroe Islands are not an EU member state and therefore cross border integration is unlikely. Cross border integration maturity in the Faroe Islands is therefore low.